Plush vs. Firm: What's the Right Mattress for You?
Choosing between a plush and firm mattress can be a difficult task. There's no industry standard or uniform specification used to measure firmness.
In fact, many manufacturers have a unique mattress firmness scale, meaning grades of softness and firmness can vary widely by brand.
Firm, plush, soft, and their many variations (think: cloud-like, cushiony, or in-between descriptors like medium firm) are subjective qualities meant to describe how a mattress might feel to any one individual.
So what's a mattress shopper to do?
First, understand a little bit more about what "plush" or "firm" in a mattress really means and how it differs from that other essential quality, support.
Below, learn about the differences between plush and firm mattresses, whether your mattress being plush or firm factors into sleep, and get answers to your most commonly asked questions about mattress firmness.
Plush vs. firm mattresses: What’s the difference?
A firm mattress is any mattress that provides you with strong support, while a plush mattress offers more cushioning and feels easier to sink into. The level of firmness you need in your mattress depends on your body weight, sleep style, joint health, and personal preference.
It’s important to note that whether a mattress feels plush or firm varies from brand to brand and individual to individual.
“Mattress firmness is a comfort term," says Robert Oexman, North Carolina-based chiropractor and director of the Sleep to Live Institute, which leads research on how the sleep environment affects sleep quality.
One company's “medium firm" mattress could be just as firm as another's “extra firm" mattress. “When an elephant lies down on a mattress, for example, it's going to feel different than when a mouse lies on that same mattress," says Oexman.
While there's no definitive standard, many mattress companies (including Saatva) rate the firmness of their products on a 10-point scale.
Typically the higher the number, the firmer the mattress, from 3-4 at the low end to 7-8 at the high end.
Plush vs. firm mattress comparison chart
Here's how plush and firm mattresses stack up against each other:
-Helps reduce pressure points
-May not provide enough support for proper spinal alignment
-People with shoulder pain, hip pain, or lower back pain
-Lighter weight people
-Helps promote neutral spinal alignment
-May be uncomfortable for people with back pain or bad joints
Different sleeping positions need different comfort levels
When it comes to mattress firmness, one important consideration is your typical sleeping position.
If you're a side sleeper, for example, you have concentrated pressure points in contact with the mattress: your shoulder, hip, and outside of your knee and foot. In that case, a softer mattress lets you sink in and provides better pressure relief.
If you're a stomach sleeper, you'll probably do better on a firmer mattress, which will help prevent arching in the back (and potential pain later on).
And if you're a back sleeper, count yourself lucky. You will likely sleep well on most types of mattresses, as long as it's not so soft or firm that it throws your spine out of neutral alignment. (Here's more advice on how to match your mattress to your sleep position.)
A mattress doesn't need to be firm to be supportive
A plusher mattress can still be supportive. Support comes from the core of the mattress—the denser bottom layers of foam in foam mattresses and the spring system in an innerspring mattress—not from how firm or plush the surface layers, or "comfort layers," feel.
Oexman defines support as the ability to adopt a variety of positions throughout the night while maintaining your spine in a relatively “neutral" horizontal position.
In other words, you want to avoid the U-shaped curve you'd get from sleeping in a hammock, as well as the unnatural bend you'd experience if you lie on your stomach on the floor all night. Instead, your spine should be supported in its natural S-shaped curve and your ears, shoulders, and hips should be aligned.
A soft or ultra-plush bed can still provide plenty of support, Oexman says, so long as the layers underneath are appropriate for the person who's sleeping on it. “You can still go ahead and sink into it enough to get the support you need," he says. (Here's how to match your mattress to your body type.)
Then, for your best night's sleep, focus on mattress comfort. Choose the firmness or softness that feels most comfortable to you, and you can't go wrong.
These Saatva Mattresses Are Available in a Variety of Comfort Levels
Mattress firmness FAQs
Are plush mattresses good for back pain? Are firm mattresses uncomfortable? We're answering your most commonly asked questions to help you decide on the right firmness level for you.
Are plush mattresses good for back pain?
Softer mattresses can be a good alternative for someone who's having back pain with their existing medium firm or firm mattress. They can also be a great choice for side sleepers who are having back pain with their existing mattresses.
Is a firm mattress good for your back?
Firm mattresses can be a good option for people who have lower back pain. A firmer mattress can offer support that keeps your lower back from sinking—and it can help distribute your weight evenly.
However, a firm mattress isn’t always best for back pain. Other factors come into play, like sleep style and body type.
Do plush mattresses wear out faster?
A quality plush mattress should last anywhere from seven to 10 years, which is about the same range as firm mattresses. A mattress’s lifespan doesn’t rely on firmness level as much as quality and materials used.
Are plush mattresses good for side sleepers?
Plush mattresses can be a good choice for side sleepers. The softer feel allows the mattress to contour to the curves of your body and spine to deliver more pressure relief under shoulders and hips.
Are firm mattresses uncomfortable?
This is really a matter of preference. While firm mattresses aren’t usually as soft or flexible as plush mattresses, they can certainly be very comfortable—especially for those who prefer a firmer mattress.
Is a firm or plush mattress better?
Whether you prefer a firm or plush mattress depends on factors like sleep position, body type, and personal comfort preferences. Again, the quality of your mattress will have more to do with the brand you choose and the materials used in its construction.
It’s hard to say one type is definitively “better” than another.
Plush vs. firm mattress: What's the best mattress for you?
While lack of support is what causes you to wake up with back or shoulder pain or feeling like you didn't get a good night's sleep, Oexman says, comfort plays a role in how quickly you fall asleep versus how much you toss and turn once your head hits the pillow.
So, consider both the support you need as well as what is most comfortable for you to find your perfect mattress.
Our mattresses come in a variety of firmnesses to suit every sleep style. Try a new Saatva mattress for 180 nights to see if one of our plush, medium firm, or firm mattresses is right for you. If you decide your initial selection isn't right for you, you have the option to exchange your mattress for another firmness during the trial period.